Analysis: Gov. John Kasich on the Environment

  • Ohio governor John Kasich. Photo: Marc Nozell via Flickr

July 31, 2015

Though almost all climate scientists agree that human activity is causing changes in the climate, so-called “climate deniers” continue to gain traction in the Republican presidential field. Texas Senator Ted Cruz, for example, calls climate change “pseudoscientific theory.”

“And my view on this is simple,” Cruz said in a recent late-night television appearance. “Debates on this should follow science and should follow data. And many of the alarmists on global warming, they’ve got a problem because science doesn’t back them up.”

So when Ohio Governor John Kasich announced earlier this month that he’s running for president, he stood out—in part, because he acknowledges that climate change is real. For instance, when Jeb Bush criticized Pope Francis’s recent call for action on climate change, Kasich had a different response.

“I respect what the Pope said,” Kasich said. “My feeling is what he said, that we have an obligation to the environment.”

The question for many is what a President Kasich would do about climate change. Kasich has come out against action by the Obama Administration to curb carbon emissions. Obama’s Clean Power Plan aims to cut a third of carbon emissions from the electricity sector by 2030. But that could be a tough pill to swallow in Ohio, where two-thirds of electricity came from coal last year. Emissions from coal are considered the largest contributor to global climate change in the U.S. 

Kasich has said the state will continue to burn coal without apology. Under his leadership, Ohio joined a lawsuit to challenge the Clean Power Plan rules before they were released. The lawsuit failed.

“Governor Kasich is not necessarily your truest, bluest, greenest friend on the environment, nor is he an arch enemy of the environment,” says Jack Shaner of the Ohio Environmental Council, a citizen environmental group.

Kasich was slammed by environmental groups last year for freezing Ohio’s renewable energy program for two years. The program required utilities to replace some energy from coal with alternatives like solar and wind. But Shaner says without Kasich, the Republican legislature would have completely eliminated the clean energy mandate.

“Governor Kasich gets credit for salvaging and holding the wolf from the door so we did not suffer an outright repeal of our clean energy standards,” Shaner says. “But we were disappointed he wasn’t more active earlier in that debate, and [didn’t] exert his leadership to get the legislature to back down.”

Kasich has split with some in his own party by pushing a tax on the oil and gas industry. There’s a similar debate over a gas tax in Pennsylvania, where many Republicans say it would drive the industry away. Kasich, however, sees things differently.

“I'm disappointed by those who say the severance tax reform will kill the industry,” Kasich said in his state of the state speech earlier this year. “That's a joke. That's a big fat joke because I've talked to them in private. And I'll tell you what, our severance tax will still be competitive with other energy-rich states.”

The Ohio Environmental Council praises Kasich for these efforts—and for preventing oil and gas drilling in state parks. Jack Shaner says Kasich has also put a lot of funding into reducing toxic algae in Lake Erie. On the other hand, Shaner says Kasich started something called the Common Sense Initiative that’s made it difficult to create new environmental regulation—especially if it comes at any cost to the private sector. 

“This is sort of the mystique of John Kasich,” Shaner says. “You just cannot categorize the guy. He is complicated.”