Changes at the Clairton Coke Works

August 27, 2008

The Allegheny County Health Department has called US Steel the best and worst of the county's industries the best in terms of jobs; the worst in air quality. The Clairton Coke Works is a big reason the county was named the smoggiest place in America, topping even Los Angeles. US Steel has been ordered to reduce emissions at the coke works at a cost of more than a billion dollars. But will that be enough? The Allegheny Front's Deborah Weisberg has the story as part of our series, Clearing The Air.

At dusk on a summer evening, Lee Lasich walks in the shadow of US Steel's Clairton Coke works, a massive plant - one of the largest in the world. It employed her father, her husband, and many of her Mon Valley neighbors. They've lived with pollution all their lives.

"People are coming down with heart conditions, lung conditions, bronchial diseases we don't have answers for," Lasich said.

Lasich never thought of herself as an activist. But when her husband died of cancer at the age of 53, this mother and legal secretary was convinced his job at the coke works is what destroyed his health.

"He always told me whenever he was working in plant, always remember, he said 'I've been exposed to benzene, toluene and different carcinogens down there.' He said, 'It's terrible down there but they don't acknowledge that down there.'"

After her husband's death, Lasich joined Clean Water Action, an environmental watchdog group that has lobbied for changes at the coke works.

"The reason I got involved in CWA is I started learning that there had been so many people diagnosed with cancer and dying of cancer over the years," she said. "A friend of mine asked me to come to a meeting, so I decided that maybe, just maybe, somebody had to do something."

The Allegheny County Health Department concedes that emissions from the coke works increase the risk of lung and heart disease and other illnesses. Jim Thompson is a chemical engineer who heads the health department's air quality division.

"The plant does emit known carcinogens...the new project will significantly reduce those known carcinogens...however, it's very difficult for us to pinpoint whether one particular person's cancer is caused by that plant," he said.

Thompson's staff approved US Steel's plan to install new coke ovens that will reduce soot by 42%, and oxides of nitrogen, a key component of smog, by half, this after millions of dollars in pollution fines US Steel has paid the county over the years. The new ovens are from a Germany company, UDA. Thompson said they are the best on the market.

"This technology is on the cutting edge and addresses a lot of problems that were inherent with the old by-product recovery process," he explained. "The key element is that the ovens are operated under a very low pressure so that leaks coming from the ovens and the off-take piping are minimized."

US Steel would not let the Allegheny Front visit the plant or talk to us on tape, but its coke-making process is a century old. It involves heating coal until it's hardened into coke, which is used as a fuel in steel mills. It also produces a byproduct fuel, like natural gas, which contains a significant amount of hazardous air pollutants like benzene, (toluene) and zylene. They're released into the atmosphere when oven doors are opened or ovens leak.

Coke-making is inherently dirty and always will be, according to Richard Freuhan, the US Steel-endowed professor in iron and steel research at Carnegie-Mellon University.

"You will never make it 100 percent clean, you can continue to make it more and more acceptable, but it's always going to be an environmentally-challenged process," said Freuhan.

Freuhan says even the best available technology isn't fail-safe.

"When everything is running perfectly, the emissions are acceptable within limits, it's not so bad particularly with the new technology US Steel is putting in but when there are perturbations or accidents or escapes or failures of equipment then there is a large emissions release and that's always going to be a problem," he said.

Given a record high demand for coke and its end product steel, the Clairton mills will be operating for a long time. And as much as the new ovens will cut pollution, they won't be enough to bring the county into compliance with air quality standards, Thompson says, because USS isn't the region's only polluter.

"The project with USS is certainly going to bring us a long way towards attainment, but it won't do it by itself," said Thompson. "About 70% of the pollution in Allegheny County is actually transported into county by sources along the Ohio River so there has to be controls upwind of us in order to bring us into attainment."

And those industries are outside the county's control. Upgrades at US Steel will begin next year and continue for six years. For Lee Lasich, they can't come soon enough. "I hope it works. I really do."