News Analysis: US Coast Guard's Great Lakes Anti-Terrorism Plan

The US Coast Guard's plan to defend against terrorism on the Great Lakes has created a firestorm of protest. Ann Murray joins Matthew Craig to discuss the agency's recently revealed proposal and why some people are so adamantly opposed to it. <br>

Read the transcript »Close the Transcript

Transcript

OPEN: The US Coast Guard's plan to defend against terrorism on the Great Lakes has created a firestorm of protest. Ann Murray is with me to discuss the agency's recently revealed proposal and why some people are so adamantly opposed to it.


M: What kind of action has the Coast Guard suggested that has gotten all of this attention?

A: The agency wants to routinely mount machine guns on their cutters and small boats on all five of the Great Lakes. And for the first time, use areas off shore to set up permanent live fire practice zones with their new weapons.

M: This has never happened before?

A: The Navy did some military training on the great lakes during War World One and Two but nothing permanent has ever been set up there. In fact, the New York Times reports that this proposal is so unusual that the United States has had to negotiate with Canada to stay within a 189-year-old treaty that limits weapons on the Great Lakes.

M: How would the off shore practice zones be set up?

A: The areas would be about 5 miles away from the coastline near more than 30 populated locations around the Lakes. Cleveland, Duluth, Rochester, Milwaulkee have been mentioned. These so called "safety zones" would be about 70 square miles and would be used 2 or 3 times a year.

M: What about off of Pennsylvania's Lake Erie coast?

A: Yes, a practice area off shore from the city of Erie is proposed.

M: Earlier, we said that the proposal was recently revealed?

A: Yes, the plan has been in the works for some time but the Coast Guard admits that they didn't make much of an effort to let the public know about it. The guard has already conducted 24 training sessions on the Great Lakes but stopped last month when citizens found out about the sessions.

M: They didn't post notice in the Federal Register that the agency planned to do this?

A: They did in early August but people who have objected to the plan said it was buried in the register- a site most people don't usually read- and the Coast Guard, now part of the Department of Homeland Security, didn't get the word out about public comment.

M: What are people's specific objections to the Guard's anti-terrorist plans on the Great Lakes?

A: Most fear for boaters and anglers safety. The practice zones as I mentioned are well offshore but cover a big area and the worry is that boaters and people who are fishing can wander into these areas unaware. The machine guns can shoot 650 rounds a minute that can travel 4,000 yards.

M: What about specific environmental worries?

A: Environmentalists have offered complaints about the amount of lead from all the rounds that could be sent to the lake bottoms during practice. The proposed exercises are estimated to deposit as much as 6,900 pounds of lead and 2,800 pounds of copper into the lakes each year.

M: How has the Coast Guard answered these objections?

A: The agency says they've chosen training areas carefully- all five miles away from shore and Canadian waters, far away from shipping lanes and environmentally sensitive areas.

M: How would boaters be notified about practice sessions?

A: On marine radio frequencies and the Coast Guard said there would always be a safety observer.

M: Are people satisfied with those answers?

A: Some but certainly not all. Some people have said that it's a big open border with Canada and you never know where terrorists will strike. But many boaters say they don't listen to their marine radios unless they expect bad weather so some towns, professional fishing guides have expressed worry that anglers and tourists will stay away.

M: How have Canadians along the Lakes responded?

A: Some mayors of cities on the Canadian side say they feel like they've been duped. They think this kind of militarzation on the Great Lakes would set a bad precedent.

M: When do public meetings about this proposed plan begin?

A: There will be nine public meetings. Some start this week and will run through mid-November. A meeting will be held in Erie on November 3rd.

M: Thanks for the information.

A: My pleasure, Matthew.