Old Farming Ways, New Food Safety Expectations

September 22, 2010

After the latest round of foodborne illness--this time from eggs, consumer groups are pressuring the U.S. Senate to put food safety on its front burner. Amish farmers in one area co-op have worried that they'll be expected to conform to practices violating their religious beliefs. But they're learning that they may be able to follow models used by other Amish farmers.

READ THE TRANSCRIPT

Read the transcript »Close the Transcript

Transcript

OPEN: After the latest round of foodborne illness--this time from eggs, consumer groups want the U.S. Senate to put food safety on its front burner. Amish farmers in one area co-op have worried that theyíll be expected to conform to practices violating their religious beliefs. But theyíre learning that they may be able to follow models used by other Amish farmers.

To learn more, I visit an Amish farm in Sligo, between Erie and Pittsburgh.

HORSE DRAWN CART SOUNDS

On a sunny afternoon, a horse-drawn buggy pulls up with dozens of boxes of butternut squash. An Amish family hops off and starts unloading the vegetables into a warehouse.

PALLET AND WAREHOUSE SOUNDS

Clarion River Organics manager Zeb Bartels works inside, moving pallets of big boxes of potatoes and squash.

He stops for a moment to give a tour.

BARTELS: This is the icehouse owned by Aaron Schwartz, the biggest of the farmers in the co-op. This is where all his produce is stored and washed.

JORDAN: Ice house is not a figurative term. While not Amish himself, Bartels works with the religious farmers, who still use huge blocks of ice from ponds frozen in the winter. The blocks are dragged into sealed rooms to refrigerate produce and even ice cream.

Clarion River Organics helps to feed a growing demand for locally produced food and helps Amish farmers, who shun driving, to get their foods to busy marketplaces.

BARTELS: Sometimes I wonder if they see us as their workhorses or if they see themselves as our workhorses because sometimes it feels either way.. but we try to take care of each other.

JORDAN: The model's been a success. Bartels oversaw the building of a new warehouse last year for the growing business. Amish men donated labor to construct it in one rainy week and it can use BOTH ice blocks, as well as electric refrigeration.

But there are areas in which the co-op cannot or will not compromise. This has cost the farmers some buyers.

Wegmans, a large grocer with stores in Erie and State College, dropped Clarion River Organics as a supplier. That's because the co-op didn't meet certain standards that the USDA declares voluntary, but wholesale buyers are increasingly adopting. Theyíre known as good agricultural practicesóGAP standards for short. Bartels had a hard time seeing the farm meeting the standards.

BARTELS: One of them that I know would be tough for us is wash water, the water used to wash your produce or to wash your harvest baskets that youíre putting your produce into, has to have a certain level of chlorine in it to keep it sanitized.. You're expected to monitor your parts per million of chlorine in your water which requires expensive monitoring equipment and of course electricity which would make it out of reach for Amish growers.

JORDAN: The Food Safety Modernization Act, a Senate Bill which stalled previously, makes some elements of GAP certification mandatory. Following this week's hearings on egg contamination, the bill's expected to pick up steam. But Bartels is feeling more at ease about meeting, and even exceeding, new food safety standards. That's thanks to The Progress Fund, a community development nonprofit. Mikal Merlina, is under contract with The Progress Fund to work with Bartels and other small farms in the region.

MERLINA: Our goal is to get them certified so they keep food in the local market, so whatever that takes.

JORDAN: No matter what happens with the Food Safety Modernization Act, increasingly stringent standards are expected from the marketplace. Merlina is confident that Amish farmers will be able to stay in the game. To show how it can be done, he's looked to the Good Natured Family Farms. That's a co-op in Kansas City that includes many Amish growers.

It adopted GAP certification once major buyers like the Chipotle Mexican Grill restaurant chain required it. Complying meant that a community that doesn't use computers had to have planning and documentation forms printed out and filled out by hand. Older Amish children used coloring books to teach their younger siblings about safe food handling. And to cut costs, the co-op created a food safety plan that each member follows. The group receives one certification instead of designing and paying for multiple plans. Good Natured Family Farms Farm to Market coordinator Diana Endicott says this has taught an important lesson.

ENDICOTT: The USDA and small family farms can work together so that we can achieve the ultimate goal which everyone is wanting which is a safe food product.

JORDAN: This is a comfort to Bartels, whose income, and his future, are tied to his Amish coworkers.

BARTELS: I really enjoy it and I like working with these guys a lot. And I'm learning a lot that I can use once I work my way back to farming, rather than selling and drivingÖI'll get to be a member of the co-op as a full-time farmer someday.

JORDAN: For The Allegheny Front, I'm Jennifer Szweda Jordan.